Open Shelving vs. Closed Cabinets: What Works Best?

When it comes to designing your dream kitchen, one of the key decisions you'll face is whether to go with open shelving, closed cabinets, or a combination of both. Each option has its unique advantages and aesthetic appeal. As experienced kitchen cabinet maker know, the choice often comes down to your lifestyle, storage needs, and overall kitchen design.

In this blog, we’ll compare open shelving and closed cabinets to help you determine what works best for your kitchen.

1. Understanding Open Shelving

Open shelving has gained popularity in modern kitchen design due to its clean, airy look and ease of access.

Pros of Open Shelving:

• Aesthetic Appeal: Open shelves make your kitchen look spacious and contemporary. They create visual interest and allow you to showcase stylish dinnerware, plants, or decor.
• Easy Access: Items are always within reach. You won’t need to open and close doors while cooking or entertaining.
• Cost-Effective: Open shelves generally cost less than custom cabinets, making them a budget-friendly option.

Cons of Open Shelving:

• Maintenance: Open shelves require frequent dusting and organising. Everything is on display, so neatness is a must.
• Limited Storage: Open shelving may not suit homes with limited space or a need to store bulky or unattractive items.

Many custom kitchen cabinet makers recommend using open shelving sparingly, often as a feature near sinks or cooktops for storing frequently used items or decorative pieces.

2. The Classic Choice: Closed Cabinets

Closed cabinets are the traditional choice in kitchen design and remain a staple in both modern and classic kitchens.

Pros of Closed Cabinets:

• Ample Storage: They offer generous concealed storage, ideal for hiding mismatched dishware, small appliances, and pantry items.
• Neat Appearance: Closed doors help maintain a tidy look even when things inside aren’t perfectly organised.
• Protects Contents: Items are shielded from dust, grease, and sunlight, which is especially important for food, cookware, or fine china.

Cons of Closed Cabinets:

• Visual Bulk: In smaller kitchens, too many closed cabinets can feel heavy or cramped.
• Less Display Space: Unlike open shelving, closed cabinets don’t offer an opportunity to show off your favourite kitchenware.

Professional kitchen cabinet makers in Australia often recommend a layout that maximises storage while preserving the kitchen's openness, especially in compact or apartment-style kitchens.

3. Design Considerations: Which Works for Your Kitchen?

Here are some key factors to consider when choosing between open shelving and closed cabinets:

Kitchen Size and Layout

• In small kitchens, open shelving can create a feeling of space. However, too many open shelves can lead to clutter.
• In large kitchens, a combination of both can offer flexibility—closed cabinets for bulk storage, open shelves for decorative appeal.

Your Lifestyle

• If you're highly organised and enjoy styling your kitchenware, open shelves may suit you.
• If you prefer a fuss-free, easy-to-maintain space, closed cabinets are the better option.

Cleaning Habits

• Open shelves require regular dusting. If that sounds like a chore, stick with closed cabinets.

Leading kitchen cabinet makers near you will assess these lifestyle factors before suggesting a layout that fits your daily routine and cleaning preferences.

4. Blending Both for a Balanced Look

Why choose just one? A popular approach among homeowners and cabinet designers is to blend open shelving with closed cabinetry.

Ideas for Combining Both:

• Use open shelves above a coffee station or in a corner to display mugs, jars, or plants.
• Install closed base cabinets for storing pots, pans, and items you don’t want visible.
• Consider glass-front cabinets as a stylish compromise between open and closed—offering visibility without full exposure.

Custom kitchen cabinet makers in Melbourne, Sydney, and Brisbane are seeing more clients opt for this hybrid approach, which balances functionality with visual interest.

5. Material and Finish Options

Whether you choose open shelves or closed cabinets, the material and finish will influence your kitchen’s overall style.

• Timber shelves or cabinets add warmth and are perfect for rustic or Hamptons-style kitchens.
• Matte or gloss white cabinetry works well in modern or minimalist spaces.
• Black or navy cabinetry offers a bold contrast and a touch of luxury.

Experienced bespoke kitchen cabinet makers can guide you on the best materials and finishes to match your interior theme.

Final Verdict: What Works Best?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer—the best choice depends on your space, preferences, and how you use your kitchen. Open shelving suits those who love a clean, styled look and don’t mind frequent upkeep. Closed cabinets are better for households seeking maximum storage and easy maintenance.

A balanced design with both elements can offer the best of both worlds, enhancing your kitchen’s practicality and personality.